Here’s Why You Should Measure Coaching Efficacy

Coaching is one of the best tools for developing and retaining talent within an organization. Even more so for executives and leaders who are often less likely to participate in training programs.

The anecdotal evidence from coaching suggests that the outcomes for executives can be profound, but how do we know for sure? When evaluating the success of coaching, Return on Investment (ROI) is a key metric for top executives.

The effectiveness of coaching can often be difficult to quantify, but superior coaching has been shown to have a positive impact on overall performance. In order to accurately gauge effectiveness, one must delve into the situation beyond mere appearances. It is important to note that individuals do not exist and evolve in a vacuum; instead, they are constantly interacting with an environment that is continually shifting. This can lead to changes in the goals of those being coached and help coaches in bettering the coaching process. Measuring efficacy here is not only about success and reward, but also about identifying the next steps at an individual or group coaching level.

Measuring the coaching efficacy of your employees is important for both you and them. Here are a few handy steps that will ensure you get the right insights that help improve performance every step of the way.

1. Conducting a needs assessment and defining the outcomes

Work with the coach and coachee to conduct a needs-assessment beginning with a review of the opportunity to be realized and aligning it with the business goals. To ensure a successful coaching experience, stakeholders, including the coachees, should be aware of the value and need for coaching. Once the needs are known, develop an objectives list that outlines what coachees should be able to achieve. This is typically broken down into tangible and measurable goals with a timeline for success.

2. Define Success Measures

Organizations must first identify the individual metrics and strategic objectives that are pertinent to their success. These may include goals such as increasing revenue, improving talent retention, empowering leaders, and encouraging greater intra-team communication. Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) should be established to track progress and measure the impact of coaching on reaching these objectives and reinforcing core values and long-term missions.

Prior to coaching, individuals can be encouraged to engage in a 360-degree assessment to rate their ability to achieve identified goals, such as work performance, communication and adaptability. The results of this assessment set a benchmark to be evaluated after an individual or team coaching engagement is finished as well as identify how they are perceived and what actions need to be taken for improved performance and greater impact.

3. Setting up appropriate measurement tools and tracking progress

Coaching is an effective method for encouraging progress and success, as it promotes accountability and transparency between the coach and coachee. To ensure that progress is accurately tracked, appropriate measurement tools such as checklists or questionnaires, and quarterly before-and-after surveys to measure how coaching helped new leaders accelerate their development should be implemented.

To ensure successful implementation of change and maintain awareness of any potential needs, having review sessions with stakeholders at the start, middle, and end of the coaching process can be beneficial. It is important to recognize that change does not take place in a vacuum; consequently, having a comprehensive support system is integral to its realization. In addition to individual coaching, team coaching may also be employed - typically with an aim to increase team productivity and morale.

Regular reviews of the results allow coaches to identify areas where they can improve their coaching strategies and provide feedback to the coachee or teams on their achievements.

4. Modify or Change Your Intervention Plan as Needed

Empowered with insights, here are a few ways you can take action to enhance the coaching process. Look to modify goals, tactics, and techniques used or even alter the environment in which the coaching is taking place if needed. If a coach has determined that a coachee no longer needs coaching, they reach out to provide resources or other assistance so they can find new opportunities.

If coaching is not resulting in the desired outcomes, it is important to revaluate why these goals were not met. Questions that should be asked include what tactics were tried and what modifications might need to be made. If corrective action is required, an updated intervention plan should be put into place with a more specific timeline for achieving the objectives.

5. Evaluate Outcomes and Endeavor Again

Continually evaluate progress to determine if more coaching is needed, whether the objectives are still relevant, and what tactics or changes might be necessary to achieve success. Corrective action encourages coachee to be more receptive to feedback and striving to achieving the next set of goals. Use a rewards-based incentive system to encourage more employees to join in. This will help snowball a coaching culture within the organization.

There is no one-size-fits-all approach to coaching; the same is true for measuring its efficacy. To ensure success, companies need to develop a comprehensive plan that outlines how coaching can help businesses flourish under impactful leadership. With a strong coaching culture in place, organizations can make strides towards achieving their desired goals. So, get started on your coaching journey and don’t forget to assess your program’s effectiveness on an ongoing basis and make necessary changes to keep everyone moving forward.

Contact us to learn more about how you can make your coaching program a company-wide success. 

1. Previous article:
2. Next article: